Ethernet UP clobbers PPP
I've been having a bizarre problem with NetBSD i386 4.0.1 -release (and before that on 4.0 -release). After a bunch of trial and error, I found a solution to the problem. That's great insofar as "it works" now, but I still don't understand why the problem was happening, hence this post.
For now I just want to give a concise description of the setup, problem and solution, so that people can quickly see where it's going. Of course, I'd be glad to post more details as needed.
The setup is a box with a single modem and single network card (a Via Rhine II, interface vr0). The modem dials up to "the Internet" and vr0 connects to the local LAN. There is no NAT or IP forwarding going on; things are fairly much out of the box. Connections to the LAN work fine.
This was the problem: When connected with pppd to the Internet (interface ppp0), this connection does not work right when vr0 is UP. If I put vr0 DOWN, the ppp connection soon starts to work right. (This is from the box, not the LAN.) What do I mean by not right? Well, it seems DNS is working, but loading almost any web page will hang up after DNS and the request is sent -- unless maybe it is a very small web page.
Note, the same thing works just fine with Linux and OpenBSD, so it doesn't seem to be a hardware problem.
BTW the routing looks ok:
# route show | head default Remote-IP UG 10.0.1.0/24 link#1 U loopback 127.0.0.1 UGR localhost 127.0.0.1 UH Remote-Host Local-IP UH
The problem manifests as errors on the ppp0 interface:
# ifconfig -v ppp0 ppp0: flags=8051<UP,POINTOPOINT,RUNNING,MULTICAST> mtu 1450 input: 44 packets, 16992 bytes, 10 errors output: 50 packets, 3523 bytes inet Local-IP -> Remote-IP netmask 0xff000000 inet6 fe80::250:baff:fe26:b0a3%ppp0 -> prefixlen 64 scopeid 0x3
So the questions are, why on earth would the UP/DOWN state of the ethernet link affect the PPP connection, and only for too small MRU's? Could this cause other problems? Is there a better solution?
I'd be grateful for any insight anyone might have on this. Thank you.
Last edited by IdOp; 9th March 2009 at 02:29 AM.
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Broadcom BCM5906M 10/100 Ethernet Driver?||revzalot||Solaris||0||15th June 2009 05:47 PM|
|My D-Link DFE530TX ethernet adapter isnt found. Help!||Quaxo||OpenBSD Installation and Upgrading||15||10th February 2009 12:23 AM|
|broadcom ethernet||jaideep_jdof||NetBSD General||0||16th November 2008 05:33 PM|
|Activating/deactivating Ethernet card||rex||FreeBSD General||9||4th September 2008 07:00 PM|
|Installing software without Ethernet Card||welkin||FreeBSD Ports and Packages||2||27th July 2008 12:12 AM|